Is Tesla Model 3 The Next Toyota Camry?
July 14th, 2017 by Matt Pressman
Editor’s Note: I’ve been planning to write an article about these two cars for a while, so it’s nice to get a bump from Loup Ventures, which has beat me to it! Check out Matt’s summary of the analysis below.
Originally published on EV Annex.
We recently profiled Gene Munster, one of the most revered Wall Street analysts covering Apple. Munster has a 5 star rating and ranks a stellar 21 out of 4,592 analysts on Tip Ranks (99.5th percentile). Lately, he’s been showing up on the financial networks discussing his outlook for another tech innovator, Tesla. His company, Loup Ventures, argues in its most recent research report that the “Model 3 could change the world.” Munster chose a surprising car to stack up against the Model 3. No, not the Chevy Bolt — the Toyota Camry.
Above: Tesla Model 3 release candidate spy photo (via reddit, Fewwordsbetter)
For 14 years running, the Toyota Camry has been America’s best-selling car. That said, Loup Ventures compared the Model 3’s total cost of ownership with the Camry “because it’s a good example of an affordable quality car sold in the U.S. At first glance, Camry is in a different segment than the Model 3, given that a Camry costs an average of 42% less than an average Model 3 and Camry is an ICE (internal combustion engine). However, looking at total cost of ownership, the price gap closes based on savings from fuel, insurance maintenance, and repairs, ultimately yielding a 13% price difference over 5 years.”
Above: Munster pits the Model 3 against the Camry (Source: Loup Ventures)
The Model 3’s lower cost of ownership could allow Tesla to tap into a bigger market than ever before. Munster concludes, “Owning a Model 3 is only 13% more expensive than owning a Toyota Camry over a 5 year period…. [so] based on our cost of ownership work, we believe the Model 3 expands Tesla’s addressable market to about 11m vehicles per year in North America alone.” Could this mean mass market success for Tesla? “If Tesla captures 25% of this 11 million vehicle addressable market by 2025, Tesla would generate $105 billion in annual revenue from the Model 3.”
Above: Tesla store in Seoul, South Korea (via Instagram, kunikuku_kung)
With a smaller-than-expected price difference, which car is the better value? “Tesla wins over a Camry when it comes to customer experience, due to its acceleration, Autopilot, elimination of gas station stops, and the high-quality entertainment system. There is evidence of this in a Consumer Reports survey, where 91% of Tesla owners state they would ‘definitely’ buy their cars again, the highest rating of any automaker. The next two closest automakers were Porsche at 84% and Audi at 77%.” Meanwhile, Toyota came in 5th place with 76%.
Above: Consumer Reports latest ‘Car Brands Ranked by Owner Satisfaction’ results (Source: Consumer Reports)
And don’t forget the viral nature of Tesla ownership: “As more Teslas find their way onto the road, the general public will become increasingly aware of the benefits of Tesla ownership and likely view the 13% total cost of ownership difference as insignificant. We expect this ‘see it and want it’ phenomenon to cause an acceleration in Model 3 demand.” This, in turn, could open up the coveted Tesla brand to the masses. Munster predicts, “the Model 3’s value, in combination with its technology, has the potential to change the world and accelerate the adoption of electric and autonomous vehicles.”
Above: Tesla Model 3 in front of a Model X at the factory (via instagram, everything.tesla)
As Tesla’s Autopilot is perfected, Big Auto will be left behind: “Detroit, Japan, and German car manufacturer feature shortfalls will compound around the end of 2020 when Tesla adds autonomy to approximately 2 million Teslas on the road virtually overnight… Note that every Tesla sold today has the hardware for full autonomy. When Tesla turns on full autonomy, we believe the market will tip away from traditional autos to Tesla.” A trip down memory lane might be in order — perhaps Apple vs. Nokia could soon resemble Tesla vs. Toyota.
Above: Munster thinks Model 3 could be the iPhone of cars
As before, Munster draws a corollary between Apple and Tesla. Apple, once seen as a niche and pricey brand, now enjoys massive mainstream success. The iPhone was what pushed Apple out to a universal audience. And Munster forecasts, “we will eventually look back at the launch of the Model 3 and compare it to the iPhone, which proved to be the catalyst for the shift to mobile computing. … Looking back at the iPhone in 2007 it was a stretch to envision the company producing 50m phones a year, but in 2015, the company sold 232m units.”